Skip to main content

How to Tell the Difference Between a Downy and a Hairy Woodpecker

Image
By
This picture of a woodpecker from my trip to Colorado reminded me how difficult it can be to tell the difference between Downy Woodpeckers and Hairy Woodpeckers.



I see far more downy woodpeckers here in Massachusetts, but when I'm at Steve's parents house in Connecticut I see more hairy woodpeckers. There's one that lives in his parents' yard and is always pecking away at the tree in the front yard. Colorado was completely new territory so I didn't know what to expect.



I remember this bird being on the larger side when I took the picture, and you can notice its elongated neck and extensive black on its shoulder. I was curious if woodpeckers were any different out in Colorado. While I was doing research on All About Birds I found a link more information about birds of the Rockies:



Based on this I am pretty confident it was a hairy woodpecker, not only because of the size, but because of the extensive black on its shoulder/back.

This picture came from Cornell Lab of Ornithology's Project Feederwatch Resources. Is anyone else participating in Project Feederwatch? I know James at Coyote Mercury is. I haven't been able to watch much lately. The way Christmas and New Years fell I was out of town on my feeder-watching days (Tuesday and Wednesday), and then this week I didn't see any birds on one of my watching days.

Anyone else have tips for telling the difference between downy woodpeckers and hairy woodpeckers?

Labels:

Comments

Christopher said…
Great post - especially considering the woodpecker nut that I am! You've nailed down the major points for differentiating Downy from Hairy here. I fI am having a hard time determining the size, I always look at the bill - Downy has a pretty small petite bill, (visual area is less than the length of the base of the bill to the back of the head) whereas Hairy has a much bigger bill (visual area equals the length of the base of the bill to the back of the head.
January 19, 2009 at 6:05:00 AM PST
Christopher said…
One more thought I had while watching my Downies here at work. Another field mark that is rarely discussed, but somewhat reliable on the males - the red patch of Hairy Woodpeckers is often slightly divided. (Not seen well unless you are looking at a calm bird directly from behind - even at a little angle this is hard to see.)
January 19, 2009 at 12:11:00 PM PST
Kim said…
Thanks for the info on how to tell the difference between a Hairy and Downy. This still confuses me to no end so the chart helps.

BTW: Great blog. I discovered it through Christopher and am happy to meet another Massachusetts birder!
January 23, 2009 at 5:35:00 AM PST
Cathleen Voss said…
@Christopher- thanks for all those great tips. I forgot what a woodpecker expert you were! The red patch tip is especially interesting.

@Kallen- thanks for the kind words. I just checked out your blog and really like your 'window birder' perspective! This is the first time I've had feeders at my home in at least a couple years and I really enjoy getting to watch my feeders.
January 23, 2009 at 6:42:00 AM PST
Kyle said…
Great post and blog, BirdingGirl! (I, too, found you through Christopher's woodpecker roundup.) Good informational blogs are always a plus to us newbies -- I'll definitely be visiting often.
January 23, 2009 at 12:46:00 PM PST
Anonymous said…
I am new to the bird-watching hobby and I want to thank you for all the great information. I am learning a lot from your posts.
January 24, 2009 at 9:01:00 AM PST
Matthew said…
We have more downy than hairy in NYC. Brooklyn's Prospect Park also presents yellow-bellied, red-breasted, northern flicker, and, rarely, red-headed. Like Christopher above, I look to the bill/head relaltionship. It's taken me a couple of winters, but practice, too, makes for perfecting.
February 13, 2009 at 6:41:00 PM PST
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Well, Here We Are — Back to Birding Girl After 11 Years

By
Well, here we are—after an epic 11-year hiatus, I’m sitting back at my Adirondack chair, overlooking the picturesque cranberry bogs we live on now. I've swapped my super strong coffee for a hoppy, locally-brewed IPA to celebrate the end of the work day, and starting work again on my personal project- BirdingGirl. Honestly, it feels a little surreal. If you’re popping in and thinking, “Wait, she’s posting again?”—yep, it’s me! The binoculars are still close by, the dog is snoozing nearby, and yes, the birds have kept me company all along. Life Lately: Birding (Mostly) at Home Let’s get this out of the way—I never stopped birding. Not for a minute! Sure, life looks a bit different now. Marriage and kids will do that to you, right? These days, “getting out in the field” means looking up at the trees lining the trails leading to the cranberry bogs I walk my dog on, listening for great-horned owls and wood thrushes, or watching a flash of yellow as the warblers return each spring. I ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Difference Between Grackles and Starlings

By
I saw a sad sight today during my lunchtime jog—a dead grackle. Or was it a starling? I'll get to that in a minute. I was making my way down to the trail along the Charles River when I saw what I thought was an injured bird in the middle of the road. It was just sitting there and I figured it was just stunned or maybe had an injured wing. The bird probably didn't have much of a chance, but the least I could move it out of the road. As I got closer to the bird I saw it had its mouth open and then I realized the gruesome truth—it was dead and was frozen in that position. I just got shivers thinking about it. The poor thing. Anyway, so it got me to thinking 'What is the difference between grackles and starlings?' I use the two interchangeably and haven't really made an effort to sort it out. Until now. I like to use All About Birds from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology as an online resource. The site is comprehensive and easy to use. (I also really like the 'Cool ...
26 comments
Read more

Killdeer Chick in Yellowstone National Park

By
These were taken at West Thumb Geyser Basis, along the beach. It was really cool to get to watch these little chicks up close and personal. I had never seen Killdeer chicks before- only adults. These pictures are from our trip to Montana/Wyoming in July 2012.
1 comment
Read more